Town Square

Post a New Topic

City looks to the sky for future transit line

Original post made on Oct 19, 2017

An Oct. 17 City Council meeting on designing a new Mountain View transit system was a demonstration of the immense challenges inherent to transportation, even for a city with access to an enviable supply of money and brainpower.

Read the full story here Web Link posted Thursday, October 19, 2017, 11:50 AM

Comments (16)

Posted by Otto_Maddox
a resident of Monta Loma
on Oct 19, 2017 at 3:02 pm

Otto_Maddox is a registered user.

Great.. no on rides the current mass transit. But let's plan for more!


Posted by resident
a resident of Old Mountain View
on Oct 19, 2017 at 3:34 pm

@Otto_Maddox - I don't know what mass transit you ride, but I regularly use Caltrain, BART, and Muni and these are all frequently full or standing-room-only. Even 1 hour train rides are standing-room-only. Without mass transit, Bay Area highways would be much more crowded.


Posted by NO TECHFAN
a resident of Cuesta Park
on Oct 19, 2017 at 3:54 pm

Looking for complexity is not the answer. Keep it simple is the answer:

1) Extend Bart down the peninsula to San Jose, so the loop around the bay is closed. In parallel modernize this system to bring it up to todays or better tomorrow's standard. Is this asking too much in high tech silicon valley?

2) Disentangle traffic modes, especially motorized from non-motorized traffic modes. Alternative and simple modes of getting around town such as bicycling and walking/running are too dangerous. Everybody has family and friends who have been hurt walking or bicycling. Make our towns attractive for these healthy and inexpensive modes of transportation.

No need to look for futuristic systems that are untested, expensive and slow to build. We need practical solutions now that work for everyone before we drown in traffic.


Posted by resident
a resident of Old Mountain View
on Oct 19, 2017 at 4:48 pm

@NO TECHFAN - I have a hard time believing that any plan to extend BART down the peninsula would be simple by any definition of "simple". More likely, it will be as complicated as bringing HSR down the peninsula and look how "simple" that has been.

Simple would be designating two lanes of Shoreline Blvd between the downtown train station and Google to be bus and carpool only then run a constant stream of old fashioned buses in those lanes. Use electric busses if you want to be environmentally friendly.


Posted by NO TECHFAN
a resident of Cuesta Park
on Oct 19, 2017 at 5:03 pm

@resident: With your solution you are only thinking of Google - a typical view in Silicon Valley, just thinking locally. That is why we are in this traffic mess. Every city and company for themselves. Nothing seems coordinated and orchestrated among the many participants.

A better solution would be to pick-up on the bus idea and have all companies and cities band together and promote a world class all-around-the-bay bus infrastructure - and yes, electric to be a least a little futuristic... Maybe with some Tesla buses thrown in the mix...


Posted by Tom
a resident of Blossom Valley
on Oct 19, 2017 at 5:12 pm

Extending Light Rail from Ellis Street/Hiway 101 (Moffett Field) through Nasa Ames into North Shoreline is the answer.

This Light Rail will be a direct link to Caltrain in Mountain View and BART in Milpitas. It will not only benefit North Shoreline workers and new residents, but also Shoreline Amphitheater concertgoers!

Years ago Mountain View paid 20 million dollars to bring Light Rail to the Castro Street Station. Let's build on that investment.


Posted by Wondering
a resident of Old Mountain View
on Oct 19, 2017 at 9:00 pm

Caltrain and Bart make sense. The VTA doesn't. I constantly see VTA's massive double busses going down El Camino with a maximum of four to five people - the exception being once or twice a day. They would be wise to use 12-16 person vans, which would be much cheaper and could be scheduled much more frequently if necessary at the few more busy times. Taking any lane in MV for exclusive car pooling or VTA is a losing proposition. Busses are a 19th century technology except for the local MV public transportation loop, which some seem to find attractive because it actually goes where people want to go. Even those are relatively empty.

I doubt there is even one location in MV for an elevated line that wouldn't be a big invasion of privacy, or invade the skyline of an entire area. I think the engineers at this meeting were thinking ahead for the Waymo style transportation, and that seems like the real winner here for a lot of our more local transportation woes.

Before we spend multi-millions on a project that will be out of date before it's even built, we need to look at upcoming modes of transportation that are adaptable to our current roads. Oh, and maybe we could stop crowding our roads by building such massive housing, and instead encourage other cities to take up their share towards the Peninsula housing effort.


Posted by Juan
a resident of Rengstorff Park
on Oct 19, 2017 at 9:50 pm

Juan is a registered user.

Waste of money! Let some other suckers pay the R&D cost for this star trek transportation system that 99% chance will fail (just look at average startup failure rate).


Posted by Peter Muller
a resident of another community
on Oct 20, 2017 at 8:35 am

As President of the Advanced Transit Association I would like to point out that there are a number of technologies similar to those offered by Baertsch and Furman that are already in public service and commercially available around the world. While we encourage the City to foster the growth of local technologies, many of their fears can be allayed by paying more attention to what is being done elsewhere, which includes a project with 75 miles of track, over a hundred stations and more than a thousand vehicles.


Posted by Jeff
a resident of Old Mountain View
on Oct 20, 2017 at 3:10 pm

@NO TECHFAN -- "Extend Bart down the peninsula to San Jose, so the loop around the bay is closed."

Well, around half of the Bay.

@Peter Muller's comment is to the point. Anyone who thinks that some futuristic magic solution is going to happen or touts "simply do x" misses the many examples around the world of successful efforts that combine old and new technologies into well-designed systems.


Posted by Oldtimer
a resident of Cuesta Park
on Oct 20, 2017 at 3:30 pm

Traffic looks grim. Housing is going up, in clever Google-Mountain View everything is being built as close as possible to downtown and Google. This leads to more traffic as everyone seems to be commuting by car. This leads to longer commutes from the folks outside - the poor ones who can't afford a KenDeLeon house - and more clogging of the roads around our towns. This means Mountain View will try to build even more housing (the logic of our city council) and the spiral continues.

The only think that could get us out of this mindless trap we are building continuously - especially in Mountain View - is some well thought out transport system FOR EVERYONE BY EVERYONE. With this I mean all cities around the bay and all major employer should pull together and design a practical and functional system that stacks up to the high tech credentials we usually like to take credit for in Silicon Valley.

Feasible? Not sure, but I really think this is the only way to go. Otherwise we drown in traffic congestion.


Posted by Googler
a resident of Old Mountain View
on Oct 20, 2017 at 4:00 pm

@Oldtimer: You should be grateful for the tech companies. They provide good jobs and the employees pay tax here. The city is right to build more housing, this way we can live closer to work which leads to less pollution. I don't think it is the mandate of the companies to organize transport for all, they already provide transportation for their employees to get us off the road. You are asking too much of the Tech companies. They do not have to be here but can leave if they so decide. So watch out what you are asking for.


Posted by William Hitchens
a resident of Waverly Park
on Oct 20, 2017 at 4:45 pm

William Hitchens is a registered user.

I totally agree with Tom's post above: "Extending Light Rail from Ellis Street/Hiway 101 (Moffett Field) through Nasa Ames [to North Bayshore] is the answer."

All of the high tech foofaraw options discussed in the article, including pod cars and autonomous transit, are just very expensive pipe dreams (which I, a former telecom startup staff scientist, very cynically call "typical start-up spin, buzz, and hype dreams". Start-ups, by the very nature of their need to raise megabucks of cash and to attract customers, almost always grossly overstate the performance and benefits of their unproven technologies. It's part of the high tech startup game/dance with investors and customers.

To move people from the MV Caltrain/Light Rail station to North Bayshore without clogging existing roads, go with a proven boring low tech solution. Light rail is proven, very boring, and under-utilized. Run a light rail spur from Ellis St. to a bridge across Stevens Creek in North Bayshore. Run light rail shuttles back and forth from the bridge to Ellis St. Make the bridge accessible for shuttle buses, bicycles, and pedestrians and NOT for automobiles.

The rails are there and the cost is sunk, except thru NASA Ames. Use them!!! It may be ugly, but it will work.


Posted by Me
a resident of Shoreline West
on Oct 20, 2017 at 7:42 pm

why would "Extending Light Rail" work?

A simple bus shuttle from caltrain to shoreline with dedicated bus lanes would do the same and would cost a lot less to implement. If that actually gets enough people we could perhaps justify investment in light rail.


Posted by Here we go again
a resident of Bailey Park
on Oct 20, 2017 at 9:08 pm

[Post removed due to disrespectful comment or offensive language]


Posted by Gary
a resident of Sylvan Park
on Oct 22, 2017 at 7:43 pm

Gary is a registered user.

George Jetson took his own aerocar to work. Where are the aerocars?


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Email:


Post a comment

On Wednesday, we'll be launching a new website. To prepare and make sure all our content is available on the new platform, commenting on stories and in TownSquare has been disabled. When the new site is online, past comments will be available to be seen and we'll reinstate the ability to comment. We appreciate your patience while we make this transition..

Stay informed.

Get the day's top headlines from Mountain View Online sent to your inbox in the Express newsletter.